For Some Questions, Motives Are Irrelevant
**
When in debate, please don't respond to a challenge with "But why would they do that?" That is irrelevant when it comes to the truth or falsity of a position, the harm or benefit of an action.
I find this response regularly comes up, especially when talking about politics. It is not that important WHY George W Bush or Barak Obama does something. Maybe Bush is incompetent. Maybe Obama is wittingly pursuing a socialist agenda. Maybe not. Either way, we should judge their ideas and actions, as well as the results. Leave the motives to God. The same goes for global warming, gay marriage, the economy, war, etc, etc.
I'd like to extend this point to say something about conspiracy theories. Listen, nothing would surprise me. Is it possible that world leaders have secret societies? Sure, I guess that's possible. However, I don't need to know these usually unprovable things in order to know that certain of their actions have negative results.
Try not to get sucked into the distractions that bombard you if you watch TV news and pundits or listen to them on the radio. Ask "is the action good?" not "is it patriotic?"

